No Progress Preventing Puck’s Persistent Peeing and Pooping Problem

It’s been a long time since I’ve talked about Puck’s peeing and pooping problem, probably because I have nothing new to report. Actually, I can talk about more ways that I have failed to stop it.

I believe my last report mentioned that we had started Puck on Prozac. I can tell you that wasn’t easy. Even though it was only half of a very tiny pill, when I ground it up and put it in his food he knew it was there and he wouldn’t eat his food.

I tried putting it in tuna and that worked better than cat food but I can’t feed the cats tuna every day. Even in tuna, he would only eat about half of the small amount that I put in his bowl. I went to the pet store and I bought a variety of different types of wet cat food. I tried to pick the ones that seemed juicy and flavorful. Some worked better than others but none of them worked very well at all.

compounded ProzacSome commenters mentioned that I could get his prescription compounded into a flavor like tuna. I looked into that and found a compounder near me called Bay Life Pharmacy. They had two options, chicken or tuna. I picked the chicken because I thought it would blend better with the chicken cat food that I’ve been giving them. It cost about $45 and they shipped it directly to my house. It arrived fairly quickly after that, perhaps one or two days later.

It came with a syringe and I put the required amount in the syringe and squirted it on puck’s cat food and mixed it in. I was convinced that this was going to work but when I put his food in front of him he wouldn’t eat it. He just went over to somebody else’s bowl and took their food.

I struggled for weeks trying to get him to eat his food with the medicine in it. I think I was averaging a half a dose a day. Shortly before Hurricane Irma hit, I reordered his medication, but this time I chose the tuna flavor. I still had more in the first bottle but I had mostly given up trying to give it to him. I could have just forced it in his mouth but causing anxiety by giving an antianxiety medicine seemed counterproductive.

While we were away during our evacuation, Puck used the litterbox. When we returned home, Puck forgot how to use the litterbox again. Because of that, we decided to try to be more diligent about getting the medicine in him. That meant we had to force it in his mouth since the tuna worked no better than the chicken flavor. I feel bad doing that. I gave Frankie a piece of cheese yesterday and tried to give Puck a piece but he ran away and hid under a chair. Not the desired result I was looking for.

Another approach I have considered is the litterbox. I already mentioned that I tried adding a box and I tried putting a box in various different places around the house. I also tried a couple of different litters as well as just cleaning the boxes very well. I also tried putting out a box with a pee pad instead of litter, which was suggested by one commenter. Nothing worked.

litter box with pee pad

One day I saw Puck investigate one of the boxes. He put his paw in it and then ran away like he just stepped on hot lava. Shortly after that, I saw him about to poop so I picked him up and put him in the box. He quickly finished pooping and then jumped out of the box and ran like a cat out of hell. That got me thinking that maybe he didn’t like the texture of the litter.

Another thing I noticed was that he tended to pee behind Rose’s chair, or under her desk or under my desk. He also peed under the kitchen table. Sometimes he would pee or poop out in the open but often the place was somewhat hidden. That prompted me to do something I recommended against in my post, Litter Boxes Are For Cats. I bought a box with a cover. I still don’t recommend it but sometimes when everything logical fails you have to try the illogical.

I needed to find a large box because a small box with a cover was too confining. I found a very large corner litter box at one of the big pet stores but didn’t want to spend $38 for another box that could fail. Instead, I looked on Amazon and found it for $18 with free shipping. It’s called Nature’s Miracle Advanced Hooded Corner Litter Box and since I purchased it the price went up to over $54. I guess I bought it at the right time.

I also bought a litter called Dr. Elsey’s Kitten Attract Cat Litter. This litter was supposed to be soft enough for a kitten’s paws so I thought if Puck was having sensitivity issues, this litter might help. I paid a little more through Amazon but I was having trouble finding it locally.

The litter box was already popular before I even opened the carton.

It was even more popular after I took it out of the carton.

Of course, the carton had its own appeal.

I set the box up behind Rose’s chair.

For some reason, as soon as new litter is put in a box, the nearest cat suddenly has to pee. I didn’t even have time to put the cover on.

Chris liked the cover for another reason.

All in all, the box worked surprisingly well for a box with a cover on it. Three out of our four cats used it almost exclusively. The fourth cat still preferred the floor. Eventually, after determining that Puck was not going to use the new box with the special litter, I moved it out to the cats’ room where it continues, to this day, to get used more than the other boxes. I don’t know what the appeal is. I have since changed the litter back to our normal litter. Maybe they like the cover. I don’t think so though because the front opening is so large that the box offers no concealment.

Perhaps they just like the large triangular shape. That makes me wonder what Puck has against it.

I also tried confining Puck to our bedroom. The other day I cleaned a box and put new litter in it, My concern is that Chris and Frankie “mark” the boxes and I didn’t want that to keep Puck out of the box. I then closed him in the room while Rose and I were at work. When I checked on him ten hours later, the room was clean but the box was untouched. Not long after I let him out, he pooped on the floor on the patio.

There are times when he goes a day or two without peeing or pooping anywhere. I never see him use the box during that time so I don’t know if he is holding it for that long. I think he doesn’t drink enough water, which is why he has bladder issues, so I suppose it is possible to hold it for a fair amount of time but two days seems too long.

I have compiled a list of everything that has worked and not worked to help solve Puck’s litter box issues.

First, here is everything that failed to help:

  • Different types of litter
  • Additional litter boxes
  • Different location of litter boxes
  • Litter attractent
  • Covered box
  • Feliway diffuser
  • Calming collar
  • Prozac
  • Spray deterrent
  • Confinment

Here is what worked:

  • Hurricane evacuation

Unfortunately, the solution to Puck’s problem is not exactly sustainable. 


23 thoughts on “No Progress Preventing Puck’s Persistent Peeing and Pooping Problem

  1. Pingback: No Progress Preventing Puck’s Persistent Peeing and Pooping Problem - Baptize A Cat?

  2. Andrea Smyth

    I’m sorry to hear this! We just went through something similar with two of our cats – it started with Dan. He began pooping and peeing outside of the litter box…ON MY COUCH. I was beyond displeased as you can probably imagine. We finally got him to the vet and discovered that he was constipated because his anal glands were compacted. Poor guy got a squeeze out, and an enema. That solved his problem. Only now my other cat, Zooey, was peeing on the couch because it smelled like Dan…fortunately Feliway collars worked for her and calmed her down. It was not a fun two weeks as I’m SURE you know, going through it all yourself. I hope you’re able to get to the root of the problem soon, it sounds like you’ve tried just about everything!

    1. Charles Huss Post author

      Thank you, Andrea. Puck’s pooping started when we bought the sofa. He pooped on it a few times and we blamed Chris until we figured it out. The peeing started because of a bladder infection but continued after the infection was gone. We are looking to get rid of the sofa.

  3. onespoiledcat

    You really have tried everything I’ve ever heard of and still that boy is not cooperating. He’s a maverick – he’s a man with a mind of his own – he’s got some SECRET requirements for potty facilities that he refuses to share – who knows what the deal is but you and Rose have for sure given him every opportunity to CHANGE and he’s not. Has to be frustrating!


  4. databbiesotrouttowne

    dood….we R sorree; we noe yur mom N dad R at witz end N we noe ewe wood just like ta …pee in peace sew ta speek…..haz dad tried sand? reel for sure make yur own sand castle ..sand…we agreez with dad it seemz de texture mite de trubull….we noe we men shuned dirt at one point; purrhapz if ther waz a mega large sheet under de box with sum dirt in it; it wood help “trackin” izzuez ~~~~~ ♥♥♥

  5. The Island Cats

    This sure is a mystery. You’ve tried just about everything there is. Would Puck take the prozac if it was made into a chewable flavored treat rather than a liquid? That’s how I get Zoey’s and she’ll eat it right up. The pharmacy that I use is BCP Pharmacy in Houston. Relatively inexpensive and they ship really quick.

  6. Mary McNeil

    One day I grabbed a jug of sand (put in a litter jug to store for use on the sidewalks) by acident and dumped it in a litter box. It actually lasts and absorbs better than litter ! It’s the smooth sandbox sand you buy at home or garden stores, nit the gritty coarser stuff ) But I am so sorry nothing is working – sorry for Pucky, and for you and Rose.

  7. 15andmeowing

    Sounds like you have tried everything, my only other suggestion is one of those people that can communicate telepathically , but they are expensive. I know Sweet Purrfections wrote of one and has her info. on the sidebar. I guess you just need a carpet cleaner for now.

    1. Charles Huss Post author

      Puck is very nervous and if he gets scared outside, who knows what will happen. I put a harness on him once and opened the door just as a car was driving by. He freaked out and we hadn’t even left the house yet.


What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.